This document provides a short explanation of what a Free format is, along with some specific information on the range of Free formats which are available for you to use.

Warning - patent and copyright laws operate differently depending on which country you are in. Please obtain legal advice if you are unsure whether a particular patent or restriction applies to a format you wish to use in your country.

What is a Free format?

Some file formats are proprietary, which means that they are owned by a company or other organisation. Sometimes, the owners of such formats charge licensing fees or impose legal restrictions on the use of their formats. This means that people may be unable to use or distribute these formats without first paying a fee or applying for a license.

A Free or open format is one which can be used by anyone, free of legal restrictions on how they use the format. Free formats are very popular - the World Wide Web is based on the open HTML standard. Ubuntu supports many free formats and the open-source community as a whole encourages their wider use.

There are a number of Free formats which are preferred over patent and copyright encumbered formats. Keep in mind that some formats (like PDF or Flash) often have public or semi-public specifications but have some restrictions imposed by their patent-holders. Some replacement formats are listed here:

Restricted Format

Preferred format

MP3, AAC, WMA

Ogg Vorbis

WMV, MPEG-4, H.263

Ogg Theora, WebM

doc, xls, ppt

OpenDocument format

Purchasing equipment that supports free formats

Electronic equipment, such as portable audio players, often support only a handful of different formats. Often, these will be proprietary formats which the manufacturer of the device has obtained a license to use or similar. As such, it can sometimes be difficult to find a product which is able to use a chosen Free format. This section provides advice on purchasing equipment which can make use of Free formats.

Audio

If you are interested in purchasing new players (e.g. portable audio players), please refer to VorbisHardware to see what equipment is able to play these formats.

Specific format / application information

This section provides information on format-specific issues and lists alternatives to popular non-free formats.

Audio

Many popular audio formats are non-free and may be subject to legal restrictions in some countries. There are superior Free formats available, however.

MP3

The MP3 format is or may be subject to certain patents, for both encoding and decoding. These patents are being actively litigated, so usage and development of programs related to the MP3 format is at your own risk. Consider using Ogg Vorbis, which is a free and higher quality alternative to MP3 (you just need to buy audio equipment more carefully).

Other free audio formats:

  • FLAC (Free Lossless Audio Codec) for, e.g., music archival

  • Speex (high quality speech compression)

Video

Some video formats are also subject to legal restrictions in certain countries, or attempt copy-protection methods which are non-free.

DVD

Non-encrypted DVDs should play, however be aware that mpeg2-video is arguably patent encumbered and the support for it is not installed by default in Ubuntu. Full DVD-Video support requires support for the Content Scrambling System (CSS). Because the encryption is weak, using libdvdcss from Medibuntu enables one to play DVDs in a Linux/Ubuntu system.

In the United States, whether one can use libdvdcss to decrypt DVDs is governed by Title I of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA). (17 U.S.C. Sec. 1201 et seq.) Although the law is technical, it need not frighten anyone. Decrypting DVDs is legal if the decryption is done to achieve interoperability of computer programs, such as the Linux/Ubuntu operating system. (See 17 U.S.C. Sec. 1201(f)) So, for instance, if you own a legally-purchased DVD and are trying to play it on your own computer with Ubuntu, using libdvdcss is legal because you are merely exercising the license that you acquired when you obtained the DVD. However, if you use libdvdcss for the purpose of circumventing copyright protection, such as for file sharing or redistributing the content, libdvdcss would be classed as an illegal 'circumvention device'. (For a more detailed description of the DMCA, see the Wikipedia article). Because Canonical cannot know in advance what you intend to do with libdvdcss, it has decided not to include it in the regular Ubuntu repositories.

To be on the safe side if you live in the United States, only use libdvdcss to play your own movies, but don't use it to make copies so you can give the movie away to your friends and relatives. If they want to watch the movie, invite them over to your house or send them a gift card for the DVD rental place.

However, as you can read at the DeCSS information page, in most European countries DVD backup is legal. In fact, in countries such as Norway and Sweden you can legally backup anything that you own. If you do not require compatibility with a DVD player, consider encoding your videos in the Ogg Theora format.

Other free video formats:

  • Dirac (another free video format in development)

Desktop publishing and graphics

  • OpenDocument - This group of office document formats is seen as an excellent alternative to proprietary formats such as those used by Microsoft Office and is gaining widespread support in open-source office suites. OpenDocument recently became an International standard - ISO/IEC 26300. More information can be found on the ODF Alliance website.

  • Scalable Vector Graphics (SVG) - SVG is a vector graphics format developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), which is responsible for major Web standards such as HTML, CSS and PNG. SVG is recommended as an alternative to proprietary vector graphics formats such as Adobe Illustrator (AI). A list of design tools which support this format is available. For more information, see the W3C's SVG pages.

Scribus is also a good alternative for desktop publishing.

General multimedia

Other multimedia format types may be subject to legal restrictions.

Flash

There are several projects working to create a free implementation of Macromedia Flash, so that people can view Flash animations without resorting to non-free software:

Other

Other popular formats may also be subject to restrictions in some jurisdictions.

Java

The most complete free implementation of Java is OpenJDK. The free packages are named openjdk-6-* e.g. openjdk-6-jre for the Java runtime environment.

Some other free implementations of Java are ongoing in many places, including GCJ, GNU Classpath, gcjwebplugin and the new Apache Harmony. Together they aim to provide a full Java platform as Free software. Current implementations are already being used to run OpenOffice.org 2's Java components, the Eclipse IDE and many other applications.

Additional Resources


CategoryEthics

FreeFormats (last edited 2012-10-12 16:59:56 by mutoso)